In 2024, indoor golf simulators will challenge the traditional home theater as the entertainment hub of choice. With better and more affordable launch monitors combined with new golf simulator projectors, its easier than ever to convert unused space into an active entertainment area for the family and for entrepreneurs to create commercial golf training and entertainment businesses leveraging excess retail space. But what makes a golf simulator projector different than a typical classroom or meeting room projector? We’ll breakdown the differences between different types and models of projectors by looking at these key features:
According to a national survey of golf simulator users, the most important feature of a golf sim projector is how easy it is to install and set up correctly. Why? The launch monitors in a golf simulator use overhead and floor-based cameras that have specific space requirements to properly track the ball, so a golf simulation projector needs to be able to be mounted in the right place to avoid interfering with the launch monitor. They also need to fill a 200 inch or larger impact screen while staying out of the way of flying golf balls and big backswings with a long driver.
The other big task for a golf simulation is to avoid creating shadows. Unlike a meeting room screen that is mounted at or above eye level, the image of a golf simulator needs to reach to the floor to create a realistic transition from the grass on the screen and the artificial turf of the hitting area. For popular overhead launch monitors like the Foresight Falcon and Uneekor XO2, the hitting area should be between 3 and 3.6 meters from the impact screen.
So let’s look at two projectors from the leading brands that are sold for golf simulation, and what type of mounting and setup space is needed to fill a popular Carl’s Place C-Series enclosure that is 3 meter tall and 4 meter wide and often used in basements, garage, or media rooms. With 4000 lumens of brightness and 1080P resolution, both the BenQ AH700ST and the Epson L260F are sold for golf simulation and have similar price points. Let’s look at the difference between them when it comes to mounting flexibility.
Figure 1- Overhead launch monitors from Foresight and Uneekor have specific space requirements in a golf simulator that projectors need to accommodate.
The BenQ AH700ST comes with a special short throw lens that enables the projector to be mounted away from the hitting area while avoiding having the golfer create a shadow on the screen. The lens is designed to support large screens, such as the 200-inch diagonal screen in our example that keeps the entire screen sharp and in focus.
With the hitting area 3 meters (10 feet) away from the impact screen the projector can be mounted as close as 3.75 meters (12.3 feet) from the screen and as far away as 4.3 meters (14 feet) according to the ProjectorCentral.com throw ratio calculator.
The next step is to make sure that the golfer doesn’t create any shadows. BenQ has a handy Golf Sim Room Planner tool that can highlight any risk of the golfer creating a shadow. The tool enables you to adjust for the height of the golfer, so in this setup it won’t even create a shadow if you get a visit from an NBA legend.
Figure 2 - Golf simulator projectors have specific short throw lenses and offset designed to avoid shadows on the screen - even with a 210-cm-tall player.
The Epson L260F is a classroom projector that can support a 3-meter-high (10-foot) image, but it has a longer throw ratio. This means that the projector must be mounted farther back in the room to be able to fill the screen. With the hitting area 3 meters (10 feet) away from the impact screen the projector has to be mounted at least 7.2 meters (23.5 feet) from the screen and as far away as 11.6 meters (38 feet).
Using the same 180cm golfer example, you can see that there is a risk of a 180-cm golfer creating shadows even with the projector mounted less than 6 meters (20 feet) away from the impact screen. While this throw ratio works fine in a typical classroom, the use of a traditional classroom projector lens makes the Epson L260F more difficult to mount without creating a shadow in many golf simulator setups.
Figure 3 - A traditional classroom or business projector has increased risk of shadows from an average sized golfer.
Unlike a typical home theater projector 16:9 aspect ratio screen, there are a wide range of popular impact screen aspect ratios that need to be supported by a golf simulator projector. For example, most people who install a garage golf simulator often choose 16:10, 4:3 or even a 1:1 aspect ratio screen, which enables them to maximize vertical hitting area while keeping the enclosure width limited to one side of the garage.
However, since both projectors have native widescreen 16:9 resolution, how do you get the projector to work with a different aspect ratio impact screen? The BenQ AH700ST has advanced technology that with a push of a button on the remote, the projector will automatically figure out the aspect ratio of your impact screen, including 1:1 aspect ratio, and then configure the projector automatically to fill the screen from edge to edge. It will then tell your computer what resolution it needs and so your graphics card can send over an undistorted image. All in less than ten seconds.
Many other BenQ projectors such as the LH600ST also support a 1:1 aspect ratio with just a few buttons presses on the remote. For most business and classroom projectors used for golf simulation you must reprogram your graphics card to a custom resolution to enable a 1:1 aspect ratio impact screen.
Figure 4 - Many BenQ golf simulator projectors support a 1:1 aspect ratio right from the remote
Just like home theater projectors, golf simulator projectors must accurately replicate complex organic colors such as the darker green of the bentgrass at Torrey Pines, and the complex tans found in the desert rough at TPC Scottsdale to ensure an immersive and realistic image on a large impact screen. The industry standard for color accuracy is the Rec. 709 color specifications which is used in both television and home theater projectors to ensure that the colors look right.
Golf simulator projectors require both high brightness and high Rec. 709 color accuracy. Typically, home theater projectors have lower lumen and high Rec. 709 color specifications, while higher brightness business projectors often avoid any reference to color accuracy and can look unrealistic. But when a golf simulator projector has both color accuracy and high brightness so you can get a immersive experience on nearly any course like this one from Golf Simulator Videos on YouTube. Here are some examples of the differences between home theater, classroom, and golf simulator projectors when balancing brightness, color accuracy, and price.
|
Epson Home Cinema 4010 |
Epson L260F |
Sony VPL-GTZ270 |
||
Projector Type | Epson Home Cinema 4010 Home Theater | Golf Simulation | Epson L260F Classroom | Golf Simulation | Sony VPL-GTZ270 Home Theater |
Brightness | Epson Home Cinema 4010 2400 lumens | 4000 lumens | Epson L260F 4000 lumens | 5100 lumens | Sony VPL-GTZ270 5000 lumens |
Rec. 709 Color Accuracy | Epson Home Cinema 4010 100% | 95% | Epson L260F Not specified | 92% | Sony VPL-GTZ270 100% |
Native Resolution | Epson Home Cinema 4010 1080p | 1080p | Epson L260F 1080p | 4K UHD | Sony VPL-GTZ270 4K UHD |
Price | Epson Home Cinema 4010 £1,799 | £1,759 | Epson L260F £1,463 | £7,391 | Sony VPL-GTZ270 £71,556 |
According to a national survey of golf simulator buyers by QuestionPro, they want a maintenance free projector that doesn’t require replacement lamps and monthly filter cleanings in a golf simulator projector. So how can you tell if a projector is truly maintenance free – or just “virtually” maintenance free for your golf simulator setup?
The latest golf simulation projectors use either LED or laser light sources. Both last 20,000 hours or more without requiring any replacement lamps. The main difference between the two is that the LED powered projectors have better color performance and higher saturation, while the laser powered projectors can achieve higher brightness levels.
In 2024, the best golf simulators use a sealed light engine to keep the dust out of the projector. For laser projectors, these are certified as dustproof using the IP5X rating, and ensures that dust can’t damage the projector, even if it’s mounted in a garage.
Some projector brands still require the use of special filters to keep the dust out of the projector, and these filters need to be regularly cleaned. Depending on the use of the projector and the amount of dust, the filter cleaning interval can be as often as every month. The process for cleaning the filter may require special equipment or washing, and a replacement filter typically costs between £40-£80.
Here are maintenance requirements and costs for projector models used for golf simulation.
|
Eiki EK-308U |
Epson Pro G4700 Projector |
Panasonic PT-VMZ51 |
||
Light Source | Eiki EK-308U Lamp | LED | Epson Pro G4700 Projector Laser | Panasonic PT-VMZ51 Laser | Laser |
Lamp Life | Eiki EK-308U 3000 Hours | 20,000 Hours | Epson Pro G4700 Projector 20,000 Hours | Panasonic PT-VMZ51 20,000 Hours | 20,000 Hours |
Replacement Lamp | Eiki EK-308U Yes | None | Epson Pro G4700 Projector None | Panasonic PT-VMZ51 None | None |
Sealed Engine | Eiki EK-308U No | Yes | Epson Pro G4700 Projector No | Panasonic PT-VMZ51 No | Yes |
Replacement Filter | Eiki EK-308U Yes | None | Epson Pro G4700 Projector Yes | Panasonic PT-VMZ51 Yes | None |
The growth of indoor golf is growing much faster than traditional golf played on an outdoor course, and commercial golf simulation facilities are popping up all over the country. The best golf simulation projectors are rated for heavy use and can be used in a commercial golf simulation environment 24 hours per day seven days per week. Many business projector models are designed for only meeting room use, and the warranty can be voided for “excessive and continual” use.
So, if you are considering building a commercial indoor golf facility that has extended hours, you may want to look at the usage limitation in the warranty before you select your projector. All BenQ golf simulation projectors can be used as much as needed, and there are no limitations on usage in the warranty.
While the use of projectors in golf simulation has been growing, the overall market for business and classroom projectors has been shrinking. This has caused many projector companies to be sold, or simply discontinued by trusted brands such as Hitachi, Dell, and Toshiba. According to Futuresource, BenQ is the largest brand of DLP projectors in the world and has been recognized by PC Magazine for superior customer service.
BenQ has trained staff to help you find the perfect golf simulator projector – within your room size and budget. To help you make the best decision, you can reach out to one of our experts to set up anything from a chat to a complete online demo, to help you find the right projector for your needs.
We're here to introduce the BenQ LH820ST, a golf simulator projector with built-in correction tools for DIY golf simulation builds with smaller screens.
If you have bigger space or prefer multimedia entertainment, 16:9 is the best. If you have limited space, 4:3 with a custom resolution could be an option.
When you set up a golf sim in your home, there’s a lot to fit, from launch monitor, screen to projector. We show you how to measure for the ideal experience.
What is Screen Fill feature? And how it can help golfers to quickly switching projector aspect ratios in their home golf theater? Read more about the feature.