It is a common misconception that all electronics should exhibit the same colours, especially with devices with the same make and model. However, this is often not the case. Have you considered what’s actually causing the picture to look different?
It is a common misconception that all electronics should exhibit the same colours, especially with devices with the same make and model. However, this is often not the case. This is illustrated with a simple experiment: when you put the same image on two monitors side-by-side, you have at least a 95% of chance that the images will not look the same and you will probably find yourself in a situation like that shown in Figure 1. The monitors do not need to be the same make and same model, but for illustration purposes, we used four identical monitor images.
Figure 1: Different colours on the same type of device
Another place to witness this phenomenon is when you are shopping for a new TV. Most people go to a large electronics store and decide between the TVs on display. Then, you pick the one with the colours or image quality (or price) that you find the most appealing. It’s easy to visually point out which display has been enhanced by each manufacturer to deliver what they believe is the best image quality. This same principle also applies to monitors, projectors, printers and many other appliances. But despite the image coming from the same source (the broadcast produced in the store or on the TV’s built-in display video) have you considered what’s actually causing the picture to look different?
Besides the manufacturer or store tweaking the colour settings, there are another two main reasons why the colours reproduced on different devices look very different: The first reason is that the colour mixing theory behind each kind of devices is different and the second is mainly due to mass production variation.
Figure 2: (a) Using RGB coloured light to mix colours. / (b) Using CMY colorants to mix colours.
First, we’ll talk about colour mixing theory. There are two ways of mixing colours. One is using coloured light and the other one is using colorants. Figure 2a illustrates using red, green and blue lights to mix colours and Figure 2b illustrates using cyan, magenta and yellow colorants. In Figure 2a, when adding red, green and blue lights together, you will see white light. When adding red and green lights, you will see yellow light; whereas adding red and blue lights, you will see magenta lights.
When talking about these colour schemes, we often refer to cyan, magenta and yellow (Figure 2b) as ‘primary colours’, and red, green and blue (figure 2a) as ‘secondary colours’. Since colours are created by taking out the reflection of the substrate white using a filtered light medium, this method of mixing colours is called ‘subtractive colour mixing’. Conversely, since white can be created by adding red, green and blue lights, we call this method ‘additivity colour mixing’.
The difference is, if we want to use colorants or inks to create colours with ‘additive colour mixing’ we must apply the colorants or inks onto a substrate, such as paper or canvas. So consider the white in Figure 2b to be the white from the paper or canvas. On these surfaces, when mixing cyan and magenta colorants you will see a blue colour; whereas mixing magenta and yellow colorants, you will see a red colour. When you mix all three: cyan, magenta and yellow colorants, in theory, you will get black.
Figure 3: Additivity colour system
Figure 4: Subtractive colour system
When we reproduce images digitally, such as displaying images on monitors or projectors, the ‘additivity colour mixing’ method is often used, as illustrated in Figure 3. When reproducing hardcopy images, such as using a printer to print out an image, the ‘subtractive colour mixing’ method is used, as illustrated in Figure 4. It’s easy to see that the secondary colours of additivity and subtractive colour systems are the exact opposite. The same idea applies to creating white and black in both systems. Therefore, we could expect that the colours created from monitors or projectors will be different from the colours on a printed media due to the difference in colour mixing method.
The second reason we see changes in colours produced on different devices is due to mass production variation. There are different methods of producing these colours. In Figure 5 we will explain using a commonly produced monitor as an example.
Figure 5: Main components of LCD panel
Figure 5 illustrates the main components inside a monitor panel. There are at least 10 different layers of components to create a single piece of panel. The main components which will mostly affect colours are listed in the following:
3. TFT Substrate
4. Liquid Crystal (LC)
5. Colour Filter Array
6. Colour Filter Substrate
Due to the material and manufacturing process, one can expect slight variations in mass production methods for each layer of components. The variation is usually around 5% per component in order for it to be produced quickly and priced reasonably. Let’s say we tighten the quality control variation to 2% for each component used. With 10 layers of components, the variation of the panel could easily go up to 15% ~ 20%. Therefore, when the factory uses the panels right away without any adjustment or calibration, the colours will definitely be very different from unit to unit. This is the typical case for monitors, projectors, TV and even printers.
From this article, we learned there are three reasons responsible for why the colours look differently on different devices. The first one is because each manufacturer has its own colour balance preference. The second reason is the fundamental colour mixing theory is different across different mediums. The last one is variation in mass production. Now that we can attribute some concrete reasons to this phenomenon, in the next article we will discuss what we can do to make colours look the same on different devices.